17.4 C
Wednesday, September 22, 2021
Home Opinion Where do we go next? The managerial hunt continues

Where do we go next? The managerial hunt continues



Why not enter our Prediction League?  It’s free and fun to enter and runs throughout the season.  Click here for details

It has been a pretty depressing week to be a Swans fan.   From a position – and one not the many years ago – where we were able to attract the likes of Michael Laudrup we now seemingly cannot entice a manager from MK Dons to try and push us onto the Premier League.

As it stands at the moment it feels like there is a long hard season ahead of us in the Championship.   Two failed play off campaigns, the return of all of the loan stars we had last season and the departure of the manager almost two months after he signalled he wanted to exit makes for one of the worst summers we have had for a long long time.

Who is going to be our next manager?

  • Someone Else (19%, 70 Votes)
  • Cameron Toshack (14%, 52 Votes)
  • Alan Tate (17%, 62 Votes)
  • Russell Martin (11%, 39 Votes)
  • Jody Morris (27%, 98 Votes)
  • Chris Wilder (13%, 48 Votes)

Total Voters: 369

Loading ... Loading ...

And at the moment it shows no signs of ending.  In the last week we seem to have been turned down by both John Eustace and Russell Martin.  Our interest in the latter remains but his 13th placed finish in League One last year seems to be something he feels more able to build on than our play off final defeat.  Eustace was “personal reasons” rumoured maybe to be softened by a pay rise at QPR but it still remains that the Swans did not feel attractive enough to him to make the jump.  You can cite whatever else you want but that will have played a part in it.

The name of Jody Morris has been in there for a week but we either aren’t progressing it or we are unable to progress it and yesterday Chris Wilder came back to the fore although it was greeted with a hugely cynical view for everywhere that he would not come here with the budgets we have available.   We will see on that front but it is fair to say that no manager coming in will be given unlimited access to what is a relatively limited purse at the best of times.

Meanwhile Swansea legend Alan Tate is preparing the side for the home friendly against Southampton with one eye on the league opener at Blackburn for which, at this rate, he could end up still being in charge.  Our transfer business seems to be on hold until we make the appointment which is putting us at a further disadvantage as we really don’t have anywhere near the strength in depth to approach a league campaign.   A poor start – even in the early weeks – can often dictate the season ahead, we don’t want that at all.

It is difficult to know where we are turning next.   Is it a straight fight between Morris and Wilder?  Is Martin still in the frame or is that an interest that is in line with I am interested in winning tomorrow’s lottery but I’m not buying a ticket?   We could maybe end up with a straight fight between Tate and Knill at this stage or is there another name to come in from left field to catch us all by surprise?

We were highly critical (and mocked) the way that Crystal Palace seemed to lurch from one disappointment to another in their managerial search – a series of events that left Cooper seemingly in a frame he wasn’t quite fully in – and now we are falling the same way.   Julian Winter must be scratching his head and whilst there is much suggestion that the majority owners are unhappy with his performance there is little point in pretending that they are not already playing their part – Winter will be acting upon a level of instructions which means he cannot shoulder all of the blame here.

There is much speculation as to when it will end.   “Trusted” journalists are asked on Twitter and reply with an insightful “soon” so I can add to that in that it could be today.  Maybe tomorrow but if not either of them it will definitely be sometime after tomorrow.   You didn’t quite hear it here first but you have to wonder if there is some more disappointment around the corner before we settle on a final decision.

All speculation yesterday was definitely around Wilder.  He was spotted at an airport, Knill left Sheffield United so you do get the feeling they are about to link up somewhere.   Swansea seems a possibility and it genuinely would not surprise me.

Whatever happens next and whenever we make that appointment we have to stop and take stock after it and wonder why we seemingly cannot attract our first choices?   Only those involved in the discussions will know the reasons why we have been turned down but we have to review that and if we have made mistakes then we have to ensure we don’t make them again.

I’m not going into bold predictions right now as to what is to happen next.   Wilder I think has not come out of nowhere and I think there is more to it than we have currently heard but it’s difficult to know if that is a statement made from one of confidence and experience in watching these things unfold or just the plain hope that we may actually bring things to a close and we can focus on the new season.   Just two months too late but we could always catch up…

Remember again when we were attractive for Michael Laudrup?  Sigh…


What are your thoughts?  Leave a comment using the boxes below or pop over to our forums by clicking here and post them there.  If you are enjoying our content then please consider a like and a share using the buttons below.


  1. Maybe, at this moment in time, Wilder would be the wisest choice. Okay, his style hardly fits the ‘Swansea Way’, but he is a strong enough character to steady the ship at a time when we appear to be drifting into the abyss. He has a fair deal of experience at this level and might just be able to get us moving in a more positive direction.
    You are so right, Phil, gone are the days when we could attract the likes of Michael Laudrup. We are simply not an attractive prospect, and I fear for the future unless we can halt this downward spiral now. I would dearly love to see Russell Martin as our manager, but Wilder could halt the rot, and that is a necessity at the moment.
    My heart tells me a left-field appointment such as Angel Rangel, with O’Leary and Tate would take us back to being a ‘local club’. Or maybe we should go cap-in-hand to Cameron Toshack and beg him to take the reins. It’s a romantic notion, one that has worked in the past, but Americans don’t understand our tradition of ‘club’. Most of their professional sport is based on franchise. Of course professional football clubs are businesses, but traditionally, we have retained the notion of ‘club’, with the fans being more than mere paying spectators.
    I also believe you are spot on, Phil, with your comment that Winter is not entirely to blame for this fiasco. He has to listen to instructions from above, and the majority owners must bear a degree of blame here.
    Why wasn’t this resolved months ago? Planet Swans obviously knew more than was being said with Cooper’s situation. I actually criticised Planet Swans for ‘scare mongering’, but, guys, you were bang on the money, and I cannot apologise enough for doubting you. I am deeply and humbly sorry for my previous doubting comments. I will trust you fully in the future.
    Let’s hope we can resolve this situation while we are still in the Championship, allowing us to stay in the Championship.
    All is not lost …

  2. What a mess, people were going to lynch petty back in the day, god help the yanks when or if they ever show their faces at the Liberty.
    No doubt they’ll go for the cheapest option


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Phil Sumblerhttp://www.planetswans.co.uk
Been watching the Swans since the very late 1970s and running the Planet Swans website (in all its current and previous guises since the summer of 2001 As it stood JackArmy.net was right at the forefront of some of the activity against Tony Petty back in 2001, breaking many of the stories of the day as fans stood against the actions where the local media failed. Was involved with the Swans Supporters Trust from 2005, for the large part as Chairman before standing down in the summer of 2020.

Swansea City v Hull City, EFL Championship



Latest News